So I've had the htc one for quite some time now, and att offered to take it back because my screen cracked and replace it for free. Because it is within a 14 day period, I can get a new phone no restocking fee if i would like. Here are the ones i've been looking at:
Nokia Lumnia 920/Htc 8x
Another htc one
Galaxy s4
Iphone 5 (meh)
Blackberry z10
Nexus
Note 2
[MENTION=191]y0y0ninja[/MENTION]
[MENTION=81]DrinkingWhiskey[/MENTION]
[MENTION=10]Toby[/MENTION]
Nokia Lumnia 920/Htc 8x = i have htc 8x, the build quality is horrible, one of the easiest screen to scratch. Windows phone is simply boring, i prefer using my old nexus s over this.
Another htc one = if you like it, why not
Galaxy s4 = i personally prefer it rather than htc one just because it has SD card slot and replaceable battery. Lots of goodies feature from samsung too.
Iphone 5 (meh) = meh
Blackberry z10 = pretty boring, limited apps. Pretty much still immature for now.
Nexus = oh i love nexus, i just love that timely update from google and i love rooting my phone. Nexus is 1 of the easiest phone to root and one of the most customize-able phone out there. The price is really good too but i feel that it would be a downgrade from your HTC one unless they return the money differences to you. (Nexus 4 worth $350 unlock, HTC one worth like $650)
Note 2 = too last year but it is still good. My roommate has it and I could say that the pen feature is more than a gimmick, it's really good.
I vote for Note 2 or SGS 4.. Or in the least, get your HTC one again. I am a big fan of nexus phone but the phone value worth might be too different.